Decoding Overtrading: Essential Tips to Avoid It

Overtrading is the execution of an excessive number of trades that end up being inefficient and, therefore, not very profitable. Here's what overtrading is and how to avoid it.

what is overtrading

What is overtrading?

Overtrading is common for beginners or those who keep searching for the best opportunities without a clear strategy. Overtrading essentially refers to placing many traders with low returns or even incurring losses due to trading costs that can often exceed the low profits.

This excessive and impulsive investment behaviour can lead to a decrease in profitability and an increase in transaction costs.

What are the common symptoms of overtrading?

The most frequent symptom of overtrading is systematic capital loss due to an excessive number of operations in a short time. In addition, it's most common among individuals who do not have a clear trading strategy.

Can overtrading be a sign of trading addiction?

In many cases, active trading can be attractive to people who also like risk. Trading addiction, sometimes referred to as compulsive trading or trading compulsion, is a behavioural issue where an individual engages in excessive and often impulsive trading. This behaviour can be detrimental both financially and emotionally.

What is the difference between overtrading and emotional trading?

Overtrading refers to the excessive buying and selling of securities, often resulting in high transaction costs and potentially undermining investment performance.

Emotional trading is making buy or sell decisions based on feelings rather than analysis, strategy, or investment goals. Common emotions influencing these decisions include fear, greed, and euphoria.

Essentially, in emotional trading, the high number of trades is motivated by the desire to obtain immediate results or by the fear of missing out (FOMO), which can lead traders to make hasty decisions that do not benefit them in the long term.

A common quote is: “The most important quality for an investor is temperament, not intellect“, from Warren Buffett himself. In other words, the ability to stay calm and sensible in the face of market volatility is crucial for successful investing.

Emotional trading can be driven by fear, greed, or other strong emotions that cloud judgment and lead to poor decision-making. A disciplined and patient approach to investing can help investors avoid these pitfalls and achieve better long-term results.

Why is overtrading harmful to traders?

Overtrading is harmful to traders for several reasons, as it can negatively impact both their financial health and psychological well-being. Here are key reasons why overtrading is considered detrimental:

  • Each trade incurs costs such as brokerage fees, commissions, and, in some cases, taxes. Frequent trading leads to higher transaction costs, which can significantly eat into profits or exacerbate losses.
  • Frequent buying and selling can lead to higher capital gains taxes, particularly for short-term trades, which are typically taxed at a higher rate than long-term investments.
  • Overtrading can distract from a well-planned investment strategy. Constantly entering and exiting positions often leads to missing out on long-term gains that more patient, strategic investments may yield.
  • Frequent trading can be stressful, leading to emotional decision-making and further exacerbating the risk of poor trading choices.
  • With increased trading activity, the potential for making a bad investment or getting caught in a market downturn increases, which can lead to significant financial losses.
  • Overtrading can sometimes be fuelled by overconfidence, where traders believe they can consistently beat the market, often leading to risky and uncalculated decisions.

Is there ever a time when overtrading is beneficial?

It will never be beneficial to carry out more trades than necessary to expose oneself to a certain risk. However, this is different from automated trading – this uses algorithms to place trades based on predefined criteria.

How can I avoid overtrading?

Here are 10 tips to avoid trading more than you really need:

  1. Devise and follow a clear trading strategy: Make an investment plan and stick to it, avoiding the temptation to make too many unnecessary trades.
  2. Diversify your investments: Don't put all your eggs in one basket, diversify your investments across different sectors and types of assets.
  3. Learn constantly: Never stop learning and stay abreast of market trends and best investment practices.
  4. Don't be impulsive: Take the time to analyse each investment and don't make impulsive decisions based on emotions or rumours.
  5. Set a long-term investment horizon: Don't focus solely on short-term gains, consider your long-term investment horizon and make solid investments.
  6. Don't seek excessive returns: When you start looking for unreasonably high returns you may incur disproportionate risks, instead, look for a reasonable and sustainable return.
  7. Don't let yourself be influenced by the opinion of others: Do not be influenced by the opinion of other people without doing your own analysis and making your own decisions.
  8. Keep calm in difficult times: Do not let yourself be carried away by panic in times of uncertainty, keep calm and trust your long-term strategy.
  9. Don't obsess over the prices of any asset: Instead, focus on the quality of the investment and its long-term potential.
  10. Don't give up in the face of losses: Learn from your mistakes and don't give up in the face of losses, use the experience to adjust your investment strategy and move forward.

Learn more about responsible investment


How can I tell if I'm overtrading?

Signs of overtrading include making trades impulsively, trading without a clear strategy, experiencing high transaction costs, and having your portfolio performance negatively impacted by frequent buying and selling.

What causes overtrading?

Overtrading can be caused by overconfidence, emotional reactions to market movements (like fear or greed), a desire for quick profits, or a lack of a well-defined trading plan.

What are the psychological effects of overtrading?

Psychologically, overtrading can lead to stress, anxiety, and burnout. It can also result in emotional decision-making, which often contradicts rational, strategy-based trading.

Related Articles